Shield vs. Inlytics vs. Comment Rocket: The Best LinkedIn Analytics Tool?

Transparency Note: We are the team behind Comment Rocket. We wrote this comparison to be as objective as possible, but we are obviously biased towards our own solution. We believe in human-led growth over automation. This article explains why we built Comment Rocket to solve the problems we found in tools like Shield and Inlytics.

The "So What?" Problem with Data

You look at your dashboard. "Views are up 15%." So what? "Likes are down 5%." So what? Most analytics tools, like Shield and Inlytics, are great at displaying data. They are terrible at interpreting it. Data is useless without action. Which tool gives you insights you can actually use to grow?

Shield: The Visualizer

Shield is famous for its beautiful UI. It visualizes your growth curve perfectly. Pros:

• Great for reporting to a boss.
• Tracks historical data well. Cons:
• It's passive. It doesn't tell you what to do next.

Inlytics: The Deep Diver

Inlytics goes granular. It breaks down engagement by industry, job title, and location. Pros:

• Great for knowing who is watching.
• Good for ABM (Account Based Marketing). Cons:
• Can lead to "Analysis Paralysis." Too many numbers, not enough insights.

Comment Rocket: The Strategist

We use data differently. We don't just give you a dashboard login. We give you a Monthly Intelligence Report. Our analysts (humans) look at the data from tools like Shield/Inlytics and overlay it with context.

The "Comment Rocket" Insight Layer:

• "Your post about AI flopped because you posted it on a Friday afternoon."
• "Your post about Leadership went viral because you tagged 3 relevant influencers."
• "You are attracting too many students and not enough CTOs. Let's adjust the tone."

The Metric That Matters: "Share of Conversation"

We track a proprietary metric called SoC (Share of Conversation). Of the people talking about [Your Niche], how many are talking about you? This is the true measure of Brand Authority. Shield doesn't track this. Inlytics doesn't track this. We do.

Metric Definition: What is a "View" Really?

Did you know a "View" on LinkedIn is counted if someone sees your post for 3 seconds? It's a vanity metric. Shield celebrates views. Comment Rocket celebrates "Dwell Time". We optimize for how long people stay on your post. The algorithm rewards retention, not impressions.

Export Capabilities: Can You actually Use the Data?

We tried exporting data from Inlytics. It gave us a messy CSV with broken columns. If you need to present to a board, you can't use this. Comment Rocket provides:

• Executive PDF Summaries.
• Clean CSV/XLSX exports.
• API access (for Enterprise clients) to pipe data into your CRM (Salesforce/HubSpot).

Historical Data Limitations

Shield only starts tracking data after you sign up. So you have zero context on your past performance. Comment Rocket has a way to scrape and analyze your past 12 months of performance (safely) to establish a baseline immediately.

The "Dark Social" Attribution Problem

80% of B2B sharing happens in DMs, Slack channels, and emails. This is "Dark Social." Analytics tools can't see this. We use qualitative methods (surveys, customer interviews) to measure this invisible impact.

The Psychology of Data-Driven Decisions

Why do we love dashboards? Because they give us a sense of control. But often, they are a distraction. Shield encourages you to check your stats 10 times a day. This creates anxiety. "Why did this post only get 10 likes??" Comment Rocket encourages a "Monthly Review" cadence. Daily fluctuations are noise. Monthly trends are signal. We filter the noise so you can focus on the signal.

How to Spot "Vanity Metrics" vs. "Sanity Metrics"

• Vanity: Views, Likes, Followers. (Ego boosters).
• Sanity: Click-through rate, Profile Visits, DM Inquiries. (Business drivers). Inlytics puts Vanity metrics at the top. Comment Rocket puts Sanity metrics at the top. We align the dashboard with your P&L.

The Future of LinkedIn Analytics: AI & Predictive Modeling

What if you knew a post would fail before you posted it? We are building predictive models that score your content based on 10,000+ viral posts. Shield looks backward (Reporting). Comment Rocket looks forward (Prediction).

Comparison Table

Metric	Shield	Inlytics	Comment Rocket
Views/Likes	✅	✅	✅
Audience Demographics	✅	✅	✅
Content Recommendations	❌	❌	✅
Competitor Analysis	❌	✅	✅
Revenue Attribution	❌	❌	✅

Conclusion

If you love spreadsheets, get Inlytics. If you love pretty charts, get Shield. If you love revenue, get Comment Rocket.

Get Your Free Profile Audit

---

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Do I need to buy Shield if I hire you?

No. We bring our own enterprise-grade analytics stack.

2. How do you track Revenue?

We use UTM parameters and "Self-Reported Attribution" on your contact forms.

3. Can you track my competitors?

Yes. We monitor their content strategy and tell you how to beat them.

4. Is the data real-time?

Yes. We monitor your posts in real-time to maximize the "Golden Hour" (first 60 mins).

5. What is the most important metric?

DMs. Direct Messages are where deals happen. We optimize for DMs.

6. Can I see who viewed my profile?

To an extent. LinkedIn limits this data for privacy, but we use "Intent Signals" to guess who is interested.

7. Do you provide weekly reports?

Yes, we send a "Monday Morning Brief" with the key stats from the previous week.

8. Is this data compliant with GDPR?

Yes, we only process aggregated data, not PII (Personally Identifiable Information) unless consented.

9. How do you handle "Lurkers"?

Lurkers are the most valuable audience. They don't like, but they buy. We track "Profile Visits" as a proxy for Lurker interest.

10. Can I customize my dashboard?

With Comment Rocket, yes. We build a custom Looker Studio report for you.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Is Shield safe to use?

It depends on how you use it. Shield is a browser extension (or cloud tool) that automates actions. LinkedIn's Terms of Service explicitly prohibit "bots or other automated methods." While many people use it without issues, there is always a non-zero risk of your account being flagged or restricted.

2. Can I get banned for using Inlytics?

Yes. In 2024, LinkedIn cracked down heavily on automation tools. If Inlytics sends too many requests too quickly, or if its "browser fingerprint" doesn't match your usual activity, LinkedIn can trigger a security challenge or a temporary suspension.

3. Does Comment Rocket use AI?

We use AI as a tool, not a replacement. We use AI to transcribe your voice, generate topic ideas, and check for grammar. But a human strategist reviews every single post to ensure it sounds like you, not a robot.

4. How does Comment Rocket's pricing compare?

Shield and Inlytics are cheaper upfront ($30-$100/mo) because they are DIY software. You still have to do the work. Comment Rocket is a "Done-For-You" service. We are more expensive, but we save you 10+ hours a week and deliver guaranteed quality.

5. Can I manage multiple accounts?

Yes. Comment Rocket is built for agencies and teams. We can manage profiles for your CEO, CTO, and VP of Sales simultaneously, ensuring a consistent brand voice across the company.

6. Do you offer a free trial?

We offer a "Pilot Month" where you can experience the full service with no long-term commitment. We also have a 30-day money-back guarantee on the strategy phase.

7. What happens if I cancel?

You own all the content we created. You can download your posts and analytics. There are no lock-in contracts.

8. Do I need to share my LinkedIn password?

For posting, we use secure, encrypted password managers or official API tokens where available. We take security extremely seriously and never share your credentials.

9. How long does it take to see results?

With software tools, you might see a spike in "views" immediately, but it's often low-quality traffic. With Comment Rocket, we aim for "Authority Building." You will typically see meaningful engagement (comments from decision-makers) within the first 30 days and inbound leads within 60-90 days.

10. Is this compliant with GDPR/CCPA?

Yes. We are fully compliant. We do not scrape personal data from LinkedIn users without their consent.

11. Can I export my data?

Absolutely. Your data belongs to you. We provide full CSV exports of all your posts, comments, and analytics metrics upon request or via our dashboard.

12. Do you support Company Pages?

Yes! We can manage both personal profiles (for executives) and Company Pages. We often recommend a hybrid strategy: using personal profiles for thought leadership and the Company Page for official announcements.

Final Verdict: The Winner Is...

If you have a budget of $0 and plenty of free time, Shield is a decent place to start. If you want to automate spammy comments, Inlytics might work (until you get banned).

But if you are a Founder, Executive, or Consultant who values:

1. Time: You want to save 10 hours/week.
2. Safety: You can't risk losing your account.
3. Quality: You need content that builds trust, not just views.

Then Comment Rocket is the only logical choice.

Don't just buy a tool. Hire a partner.

Apply for your Comment Rocket Strategy Call today.